Harry vs. Umbridge! | Room of Requirement, Ministry, Flat Plane, More!

The Potter Discussion: Harry Potter, Fantastic Beasts and the Wizarding World Fandom

Send us a text

In this episode, we discuss who would win between Harry and Umbridge. Enjoy!
Topics/Summary:
· 1:38 Why them? I made this choice because Harry and Umbridge have been at each other’s throats forever. It isn’t very hard to believe that they might have an altercation that would lead to a duel. They are two different people that support very different things, and a disagreement would lead to something less than civil.

· 6:53 Harry’s strengths and weaknesses. He is a good wizard to start. He can think on his feet and use spells well. He is also very motivated to fight Voldemort, and that motivation will help him. The ministry is standing in his way, and defeating them is more than half the battle. As for weaknesses, Harry is too focused on saving other people, and that distraction might impede his ability to duel.

· 14:17 Umbridge’s strengths and weaknesses. She has very strong beliefs. Umbridge knows what she wants and she is willing to go far to make it happen. She might be willing to do the things Harry isn’t. She also is terrified of chaos and will do anything to protect it. However, she is easily distracted, and it wouldn’t be hard for Harry to get in her head.

· 19:40 Umbridge blasts down the wall of the Room of Requirement. Who wins? If a duel broke out and Harry and Umbridge were to lock wands, Umbridge would win in that moment. She is in her element in defending Fudge and the Ministry, and she would absolutely flatten Harry.

· 23:12 Harry takes the locket in the Deathly Hallows. Who wins? In this case, Harry would win. Umbridge is in the middle of an interrogation, but Harry has the element of surprise. Umbridge wouldn’t be able to understand what was going on before she lost.

· 26:28 The flat plane. Who wins? If there are no other outside factors, Harry would win. Umbridge won the first duel because she was in her element. If there was nothing on the outside influencing what was going on, Umbridge wouldn’t have the extra punch on her side to win.

Having anything you want to hear or say? Click here for a voice submission or here for text.
[e-mail]
thepotterdiscussion.com
Nox

Hoofdstukken

1. Harry vs. Umbridge! | Room of Requirement, Ministry, Flat Plane, More! (00:00:00)

2. Why them? (00:01:38)

3. Harry’s strengths and weaknesses (00:06:53)

4. Umbridge’s strengths and weaknesses (00:14:17)

5. Umbridge blasts down the wall of the Room of Requirement. Who wins? (00:19:40)

6. Harry takes the locket in the Deathly Hallows. Who wins? (00:23:12)

7. The flat plane. Who wins? (00:26:28)