Season 3 babey! Sorry for the hiatus. Lots of work, and scheduling, and traveling over the summer. We're back with an Aileen centric story out of Connecticut. This story came to light after a true crime docu-series created in part by Barbara's own son, and fighting to solve the decade old current cold-case. Do you think it was a crime of passion, o…

We're back guys! So sorry for the brief hiatus, we've been busy with life lately, and editing has become a back burner task for the moment. Also we do the sprite challenge from TikTok. But we're bringing a crazy ass episode about the as of now unknown murder of Keris Riebel from Ohio. Rachel, as an Ohio native brings us this case, and as it was a r…

Coming at ya suuuuper late, sorry guys! It's been a busy time, anyway. Kat tells us about the famous or infamous Crescent Hotel located in Eureka Springs, Arkansas. Built among the Ozarks, this hotel has a very sordid history, being a hotel, then colleges, then a hospital, then back to a hotel. Along with the history come the spook spooks, because …

Aileen tells us all about Amelia Earhart and her amazing lifetime accomplishments. Unfortunately she is really only known as the pilot who went missing, and never found. She was the first woman pilot to take home many different air records, and upon trying to circumnavigate the world for a second time, disappeared with her navigator Fred Noonan. Su…

Based on Kat's recent trip to England, she comes to you with two infamous haunted English buildings. Both vastly different from one another, but no less infested with spirits. First is the Ancient Ram Inn, built in 1145 and still standing, and second, the Tower of London where many an execution took place. Would you be brave enough to visit them?…

Unknown and untold for a long time, Rachel brings the tragic story of Anna and Marianne Bachmeier. Anna was just 7 when she was murdered by a human anus, but her mother Marianne got her justice...in her way. Tune in for this late night episode of the pod, and tell us your thoughts! Follow on instagram @murdermysterymacandcheese Email at mncpod@gmai…

Aileen brings a delightful combo of spooky and history in this tragic tale of the Mary Celeste, the Ghost Ship. In the 19th century a ship is found floating like a ghost. What happened on board? Have you heard of this old, maritime ghost story? Let us know what you guys think. Follow us on instagram @murdermysterymacandcheese email us at mncpod@gma…

Aileen comes to you with an anger-inducing true crime case that starts with a brutal murder, and ends with more than four false confessions. It brings up the topic of interrogation tactics, and false confessions themselves. Of course the most important person in this case is Michelle Moore-Bosko, the woman who lost her life. However, it is importan…

This episode takes on a different topic, told by Kat. You've heard of Bloody Mary, and using a Ouija Board, but have you heard of these three games? First we talk about the Three Kings Ritual, then we talk about a horrifying Japanese game called Hitori Kakurenbo, and finish out with a driving ritual meant to grant any wish called the 11 Mile Game. …

We complete our 3 part series on the infamous six queens that were married to the worst dude ever. This series concludes with the tragic tale of Katherine Howard, told by Rachel, and the survivor Catherine Parr, by Kat. So sorry for the bad quality audio on some parts, and the voices in the background of some. Kat hasn't found a quality podcasting …

We come to you with part two of the infamous six wives in English history, featuring both Rachel and Kat's babies. Hate Henry the Eighth hours continues with Rachel's tale of Jane Seymour, and Aileen's tale of Anne of Cleves. We don't often hear much about the middle queens, so we wanted to make sure their stories were also told. Obviously Henry di…

This week is the start of a 3 part saga of the infamous six wives of Henry the Eighth. Kat and Aileen doubled up this week to tackle the first two queens, Catherine of Aragon, and Anne Boleyn. Yes, this week is long! But we want to do these ladies justice for Women's History Month. With a couple of special appearances from Kat and Rachel's babies s…

Have you ever heard of the infamous AxMan of New Orleans? Among all of New Orleans's history, famous names have cropped up through time, including the unsolved case of the AxMan. Brought to you by Kat, we discuss this unsolved mystery from decades past, recounting the brutal attacks he committed through the city. To this day, no one truly knows the…

We heard of Chris Watts, but have you heard of Fotis Dulos, whose wife Jennifer disappeared under mysterious circumstances? Aileen brings this mysterious tale from Connecticut that happened in recent memory. She details Jennifer's disappearance, and the aftermath, as well as some updates from this year. Where is Jennifer? Will there ever be true cl…

We kick season 2 off with a bang....or a blaze. We're trying this episode again after technical difficulties last week. With new host Rachel joining Kat and Aileen, they discuss the many reasons why The Station Nightclub was razed to the ground in 2003. Have you heard of this true crime case? Who exactly took the blame? Why did so many people have …

Well, this was supposed to be our second episode, but due to some really annoying technical difficulties, we bring you this spooky tale from Mansfield, Ohio. This is an Aileen-centric story, and she shares the beginnings, the murders, the hauntings, and more about the Ohio State Reformatory. This prison was where Shawshank Redemption was filmed, bu…

Well, have you? Today we discuss the legend of the Blood Countess, a brutal and bloody tale, even making it into the Book of World Records as the most prolific female serial killer of all time. What were her crimes? Listen and find out! Now, this case takes us way back to the 15 and 16 hundreds, so we didn't entirely deep, deep dive, especially wit…

This week's episode is super special because we welcome our very first guest! Since Kat is visiting her brother, we welcome Matt Baggeroer to our show this week. He's super fun and has interesting thoughts on this case, and since it's such a heavy hitter and so well known, what better case to have a guest! Apologies for the poor audio quality on Ka…

Today's episode is a gruesome one brought to you by Kat, and inspired by Bailey Sarian on YouTube. We talk about the horrific murder of Tim McLean on Greyhound Bus 1170 bound for Winnipeg in July of 2008, but poor Tim was simply in the wrong place at the wrong time. We discuss Tim and why he was on the bus, and the murderer's reasons for being ther…

Oh my gosh guys! We're so sorry this episode is so late. Things have been happening, but we promise that our regular schedule is continuing this week. This episode is brought to you by Aileen, who dives into this unsolved case. Nanette Krentel died mysteriously, only found when her house went up in flames, but nothing is what it seems. Aileen tells…

Today's episode is a dark and gruesome unsolved murder brought to you by Kat! Are you familiar with this case? This tragic tale is about Elizabeth Short who had potential aspirations in Hollywood, but unfortunately became famous another way. This case is one of Kat's favorite ones, and she tells us a little bit about Elizabeth Short, her life and h…

Sorry guys for the late posting. It's been a bit of a week and editing got slowed down quite a bit, but we do think you will enjoy this episode about the infamous duo that caused mayhem in the 1930's. Bonnie and Clyde everybody! Aileen brings us this tale and actually debunks a few things we thought we knew about this couple. We all know the names,…

Today's episode is a mini-sode! With the holiday, it was tricky to find a good time to record, so we shortened it a little this week. Are you familiar with The Conjuring? Aileen and Karly were creeped out by Kat's tale of Annabelle the demon doll. She tells the brief history of the doll, and how she ended up with the infamous Warrens, and what's ha…

Today is chaotic as we welcome Karly back! Not to worry she is okay. Today, Aileen brings us the tale of Michael and Kathleen Peterson, a story made popular by The Staircase. Aileen brings us through the history of the couple, the crime and investigation, and the aftermath, including questions years after the crime had been committed. This is such …

Today's episode is a little different because only Kat and Aileen are hosting today. Aileen has some mac and cheese and Kat came with Chinese food instead. Today, Kat discusses the life and death of Princess Diana, the late, beloved "People's Princess". This is near and dear to Kat's heart, because she truly loves Princess Di, as this wonderful wom…

Sorry guys for the late upload! Like we said, Aileen is literally in the middle of a move, and Kat and Karly have been fighting off headaches all week. Next week will be our regularly scheduled upload day don't worry! Anyway, today's episode is a doozy! Aileen shares with us the tragic tale of the Sodder family and subsequent disappearance of five …

Today's story is an infamous one right out of Massachusetts, the state that Kat grew up in. In fact, today's totally creepy tale is told by Kat, starting from the beginning, through the crime, to the following hauntings in the years that followed. Have you figured it out? Kat tells the story of Lizzie Borden and the spooky spirits that still reside…

Today's episode is brought to you by Aileen, and today's special guest is Kat's dog Reyna who had a few things to say in the background. Luckily today, all three hosts came prepared with new macaroni to talk about, and a lot of extra nonsense energy! Aileen shares the story of Aaron Hernandez and his crimes, starting with his early life all the way…

Today's episode is on the spooky-ooky side, brought to you by Kat! This famous haunted ship has been the talk of many paranormal investigators and youtube personalities for years, and finally, we discuss the infamous RMS Queen Mary. This large liner originally shuttled passengers all around the world until she retired from service permanently, dock…

Today's episode, Kat and Aileen actually come prepared with various macaroni and cheeses. Karly brought with some macaroni jokes and facts to the table, because there can never be enough jokes about mac n' cheese, especially with such a heavy topic brought to you by Aileen. The ladies learn about the Watts murders, the timeline leading up to the cr…

Each week, Karly, Aileen, and Kat will share a case of true crime or the supernatural, all the while indulging in the best food out there. Today's episode is brought to you by, you guessed it, Macaroni and Cheese! Unfortunately for our hosts, only Karly came prepared, but hey, it's only episode 1. Even during a pandemic, these three cheese lovers a…

Teaser Episode for Season 03 - Merry Christmas Krampus!Door Mystery Cheese

Mystery Cheese Season 2, Episode 11Door Mystery Cheese

Season 2, Episode 10 - Bus WineDoor Mystery Cheese

Season 2 Episode 9 - Grapefruit Kava Cocktail with Ginger Ice Cubes/Underground MuseumDoor Mystery Cheese

Season 2 Episode 8 - Red WineDoor Mystery Cheese

Mystery Cheese Season 2 Episode 07 - "Citrus Wine Spritzer" Screen NoveltiesDoor Mystery Cheese