A podcast about video games, entertainment, current events and more with your hosts Zemiah Phrance and Austin Salvadore. Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/constructive-cynicism/support
…
continue reading
A podcast hosted by two professional introverts discussing the fast-talking, pop culture-obsessed phenomenon that is Gilmore Girls.
…
continue reading
How reasonable are critiques of modern media? From “Mary Sues”, “subverting expectations”, and “garbage writing”, to “toxic fandoms”, “entitled fans”, and “bigotry”, our Hollywood landscape is full of labels, some earned and some not. In Critique or Cynicism, I aim to break down these labels and accusations and, after analyzing both sides in the best light possible, give my verdict on whether the original criticism is justified.
…
continue reading
1
Bonus Episodes - Lauren Graham the Writer
1:29:52
1:29:52
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:29:52
We're talking Lauren Graham's books - non-fiction, novel and commencement speech! There are a bunch of Gilmore Girls opinions on Tumblr and we're discussing.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
5x22 We Like This Show
1:15:54
1:15:54
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:15:54
It's the season finale! You can't tell from how we're ranting, but we actually like this show! Is Lorelai the victim? Because she's sure acting like it! Rory desperately needs some comfort, but no one will give it to her. Lane is still an afterthought. And Luke might be the most intimacy-challenged man we've ever come across.…
…
continue reading
There's a lot to cover! Lorelai has a pregnancy scare, Rory receives some criticism, Luke tries to buy a house, Kirk has a ton of money, Sookie's having a baby and Jackson's getting snipped. Plus, we're discussing fanfiction and the wonder that is Archive of Our Own and how the world ends when the site goes down.…
…
continue reading
1
5x20 That's Not Rory
1:09:40
1:09:40
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:09:40
There's so much going on in this episode our heads are spinning. Rory is almost unrecognizable. Lorelai is being jealous and petty. Emily and Richard are treating their daughter horribly.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
5x19 Archaic Divisions
1:05:53
1:05:53
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:05:53
Logan is finally ready for commitment, but his family tries to derail his relationship before it's even left the ground. Paris brings in reinforcements when Doyle is sick and Lorelai needs Luke to pick up the slack at the inn. Is this the beginning of the end for Lorelai and Rory's perfect relationship?…
…
continue reading
1
5x18 That's a Breakdown
1:15:44
1:15:44
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:15:44
Could this possibly be the worst episode of the season? We seem to think so. There are filler episodes, and then there's whatever the hell this was. The Stars Hollow Historial Society make one of the worst museums in human history and Rory, Lane and Paris are all having boy trouble.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
Lorelai isn't just gonna show up to Friday Night Dinner because she and Luke got back together, Emily! You're still the reason they broke up. Rory's not just gonna leave the party with you because you're jealous, Logan! If you didn't want her going with Robert, you should have asked her yourself! And Kirk! Where are your bottoms?…
…
continue reading
1
5x16 Boundaries Abound
1:30:03
1:30:03
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:30:03
There's so much going on in this episode it's kinda hard to keep track. Lorelai and Rory are having a belated and unnecessary sex talk. Emily refuses to take accountability for her actions. Luke is grumpy as hell. Lane is not having sex until he puts a ring on it. Luke and Lorelai get back together. Did we get everything?…
…
continue reading
1
5x15 That's My Food
1:09:40
1:09:40
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:09:40
Lorelai is dealing with the aftermath of her and Luke's breakup the best she can, but we all know she's missing him. He's obviously missing her, too, but he's too stubborn to say so. Not even Fiddler on the Roof can bring these two together. And Rory and Marty's friendship is put to the test when Logan and his idiot friends can't play nice.…
…
continue reading
1
5x14 Give The Man His Space
1:15:28
1:15:28
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:15:28
Following the disastrous wedding, Luke and Lorelai are on the rocks. All Luke wants is a little time. But Lorelai has never been a patient person. What does it mean to "hang out"? Is it casual? Are other people involved? Logan and Rory set the record straight.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
5x13 Wedding Guests Twice Removed
1:24:34
1:24:34
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:24:34
Gilmore Girls is celebrating its 100th (episode) birthday and it's jam-packed with wit, sarcasm and drama. It's everything good television is all about. We're also talking about television greatness and mediocrity.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
5x12 Kirk of All Trades
1:20:06
1:20:06
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:20:06
Richard and Emily are finally back together. Rory has a crush that's bringing out all her insecurity, but was Logan leading her on? Lorelai and Luke have settled into a nice routine, while across the street at Mrs. Kim's house, Zach is being a really shitty boyfriend.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
Bonus Episode - Interview with Khalisa Rae
1:02:28
1:02:28
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:02:28
We interviewed the incredible author and activist Khalisa Rae to talk about the food of Gilmore Girls, the power of nostalgia, and breaking up with our favourite shows.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
5x11 Girl, Hooker, Prostitute, Kirk
1:22:00
1:22:00
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:22:00
It's snowing, and there's a reenactment - we've seen this before. But this time, Kirk just wants to make Taylor happy. Christopher's father died, and while most of us don't care, Lorelai and Rory want to make sure he's okay. But we start to question them when the guilt and the lying kick in.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
5x10 Chuckles in Nepotism
1:26:21
1:26:21
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:26:21
Rory's hosting a Chilton student and loses her while dealing with the aftermath of Logan's prank. Luke has a DARK DAY that Lorelai doesn't know anything about. Self-centred much? Do you know who's cuter than Pushkin? Literally everyone.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
5x09 The Slightest Slights
1:25:40
1:25:40
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:25:40
The Gilmore Girls are trying to figure out what's going on with the grandparents but they have very different approaches. Christopher is back, even though his daughter asked him not to show his face. Rory can see right through her mother, and Lorelai doesn't like it. And we're asking the tough questions! What couple's breakup made you ugly cry like…
…
continue reading
1
5x08 - Shipping Companies in Escrow
1:27:32
1:27:32
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:27:32
The party is definitely over. Rory and Dean are over! Praise be! Emily and Richard are manipulating Rory and trying to pawn her off on the highest bidder. Lorelai and Luke should be getting romantic, but Liz and TJ won't stop yelling. But that kiss...Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
5x07 They're Smitten and Passive-Aggressive
1:22:12
1:22:12
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:22:12
We've already talked about it, but we're still so disappointed in Lane's story and her first date. Luke is re-meeting the parents and they're being straight-up hostile. The scheming has begun. And I think we can all agree that this is the beginning of Logan and Rory's romance. They're already adorable.…
…
continue reading
Things are heating up in the newsroom while Paris returns to her old self and Rory starts her journey of self-doubt. Norman Mailer is stopping by the inn and we have to wonder why ASP would subject us to such a misogynist. Finally, and unfortunately, it's the return of Christopher which brings with it Lorelai's blinders. Don't tell me that Rory doe…
…
continue reading
Things being awkward between a separated Emily and Richard? Normal. Zach ignoring Lane after she told him she likes him? NOT NORMAL. Lorelai wanting to make things less awkward for Rory and Dean? Normal. Lorelai wanting to double date with Rory and Dean? NOT NORMAL.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
Luke Skywalker- Character Arc or Character Assassination?- Extended
52:43
52:43
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
52:43
I met with Professor Juan Contreras, a professor in Media Studies and ZTV general manager at the University of Akron to talk about Luke Skywalker's portrayal in The Last Jedi. This is our full conversation. Critique or Cynicism Theme: "Strength of the Titans" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 Licens…
…
continue reading
1
Luke Skywalker- Character Arc or Character Assassination?
19:58
19:58
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
19:58
In this episode of Critique or Cynicism, I bring on Professor Juan Contreras, a Media Studies professor at the University of Akron, the general manager of the student-run television station ZTV, and a known lover of all things Star Wars to break down the portrayal of Luke Skywalker in the divisive episode 8, The Last Jedi. What is a character arc a…
…
continue reading
1
5x04 - First Lady of Stars Hollow
1:09:37
1:09:37
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:09:37
Two episodes into this relationship and anyone with eyes can see that Rory and Dean's relationship isn't going anywhere. Lorelai's learning that being a girlfriend means taking your partner's feelings into account. And the town is ready for a change. But is Jackson ready to be a leader? No. He said so himself.…
…
continue reading
1
Galadriel in the Rings of Power- Powerful Elf Warrior or Overpowered Mary Sue?
12:15
12:15
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
12:15
In this episode of Critique or Cynicism, we analyze Galadriel’s portrayal in Amazon’s billion-dollar Lord of the Rings series, The Rings of Power. Is Galadriel yet another Mary Sue to plague the creative landscape? Is she reasonably skilled for how she is established? Is she just unlikable? Let’s discuss. Critique or Cynicism Theme: "Strength of th…
…
continue reading
1
The Little Mermaid- Racism or Typecasting?
14:59
14:59
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
14:59
In this episode of Critique or Cynicism, I am joined by my friend and fellow podcaster Cristin as we breakdown the backlash surrounding Halle Bailey’s casting as Ariel in Disney’s remake of The Little Mermaid. Is the backlash racism? Typecasting? Is there any credibility to it? Let’s discuss! Critique or Cynicism Theme: "Strength of the Titans" Kev…
…
continue reading
1
5x03 It's Not Computing
1:35:10
1:35:10
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:35:10
This is not a drill! Luke and Lorelai are finally going on their first date! NOT. A. DRILL. But is their intimacy a little weird? Conversation during the date leads to the discovery of a lot more plot holes. While Emily and Richard's separation is in full swing, Rory's heading back to school and meeting new people and a new love interest.…
…
continue reading
Check out the new trailer for Critique or Cynicism, a podcast dedicated to breaking down hot takes and criticisms for popular media. Train Sound Effect by JuliusH from Pixabay Radio Static Sound Effect also from Pixabay Podcast Theme: "Strength of the Titans" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 Licens…
…
continue reading
1
Daenerys Targaryen- Mhysa or Mad Queen?
11:59
11:59
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
11:59
In this episode of Critique or Cynicism, I analyze the character portrayal of Daenerys Targaryen in HBO’s TV adaptation Game of Thrones, based on George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series. Specifically, I determine whether or not Daenerys’ turn from Breaker of Chains to Mad Queen is adequately justified, given what has been established abo…
…
continue reading
1
5x02 Boring Slut Era
1:16:04
1:16:04
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:16:04
There are filler episodes, and then there's THIS filler episode. We're taking a deep dive into the episode that didn't give us much. Lane might have a crush on Zack, Rory and Lorelai make up, Emily Gilmore's in her slut era frolicking around Europe, and Dean refuses to take accountability. All that, and yet, we're still so bored.…
…
continue reading
1
Hua Mulan- Strong Female Character or Mary Sue?
10:54
10:54
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
10:54
In the premiere episode of Critique or Cynicism, I break down Mulan 2020, the Disney remake that, instead of sparking complaints over autotuned songs or lack of originality, changed the original story so much that disappointed fans labeled Hua Mulan, the titular character, as a Mary Sue. What is a Mary Sue? And is Mulan one? Let’s find out! Critiqu…
…
continue reading
We're back for Season 5! Could you imagine waiting a whole summer to watch see what happens after the biggest cliffhanger in Gilmore Girls history? Rory and Dean did something bad. Lorelai and Luke did something good. And Emily is channelling her inner prostitute. You can now subscribe to our Patreon to receive exclusive content. patreon.com/gilmor…
…
continue reading
1
Bonus Episode 4 - Quarantine Queries
1:10:24
1:10:24
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:10:24
We're not quite ready to embark on our season 5 journey so here's a bonus episode to tide you over. We're talking about queer characters, Dave Rygalski, wordle, diverse and lazy writers' rooms, and future Gilmore considerations.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
Season 4 Recap - with Samantha Grindell
1:35:59
1:35:59
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:35:59
We're joined by Insider's Samantha Grindell (@sam_grindell) to recap all things season 4!Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
4x22 The Audacity of This...
1:45:26
1:45:26
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:45:26
It's been a long season but we made it! The will-they-won't-they storyline between Lorelai and Luke is finally here - but it did it live up to your expectations? Rory and Dean are doing something naughty, in more ways than one - but is Rory really to blame? Emily and Richard finally spill their secret - but do we really care?…
…
continue reading
1
4x21 Dancing With My Emotions
1:35:06
1:35:06
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:35:06
Family dynamics are on full display in the penultimate episode of the season! Everyone just wants to brush everything under the rug and never talk about it again. Well, tough! Lorelai and Luke are getting their very special moment and it is perfection. Rory and Jess are having a less perfect moment, but the tears are rolling freely. Excuse us while…
…
continue reading
1
4x20 Can You See The Cats?
1:28:34
1:28:34
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:28:34
We hate (not really) to keep coming back to Jess, but it's kinda hard when ASP makes him such a big part of the episode. Lorelai's feeling down about her relationship's demise, while Luke is on the hunt for a relationship of his own. When Paris finally realizes that she's not about that Geezer Life, said geezer pulls her back in with his tricks and…
…
continue reading
1
4x19 Poignant Confrontations
1:23:38
1:23:38
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:23:38
We're confronting everyone this week! Jason is left stranded when Richard tries to protect his family, and Lorelai is put in a tough spot. Paris is slowly unraveling when it comes to Asher and we get to the bottom of their relationship and the power imbalance between them. Lane yells at New Lane and feels left behind.…
…
continue reading
1
4x18 Dropping Bombs and Anvilles
1:23:52
1:23:52
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:23:52
A Friday Night Dinner scene with the most pointless conversation reveals something much deeper about the show and its relationships. A second dinner with old friends turns sour when Floyd decides to sue Richard and Jason. Carole, you're a shady bitch! You knew all along! What happens when an 18-year-old gets married right out of high school and you…
…
continue reading
1
4x17 Tie Your Tubes
1:28:31
1:28:31
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:28:31
It's Paris' trip and we're all just along for the ride! We're talking about all things Spring Break and how it's portrayed in American media. We are once again pleading with you to reconsider your Jason opinions because he really is the best boyfriend Lorelai has every had up until this point. And you asked us to talk about the latest episode of Sc…
…
continue reading
1
4x16 Grief, Thou Art a Fickle Bitch
1:27:40
1:27:40
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:27:40
The Original Lorelai Gilmore dies leaving behind her a path of destruction that has only been matched by a category 5 hurricane. How much does Emily Gilmore have to take!?Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading
1
4x15 Soul-Sucking Dementors
1:13:05
1:13:05
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:13:05
The brilliance of season 4 strikes again! This week's episode is all about Emily Gilmore and her obvious (to us) depression and feelings of inadequacy. That final scene in the episode is *chef's kiss!*. We're also taking a closer look at Dean, since the writers insist on shoving him down our throats, and Jeffrey makes a somewhat accurate analogy. W…
…
continue reading
1
4x14 Breakdowns and Failures
1:26:26
1:26:26
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:26:26
Three Lorelais, three breakdowns - one more enjoyable than the other two. Gran is back and she's causing problems, like usual. You know who else is back? We don't even wanna say his name! We hate him! Sookie's showing us exactly why we have so many issues with her, the girls are missing each other and running to the men in their lives for comfort.…
…
continue reading
1
4x13 We All Hate You, You Little Bastard!
1:11:30
1:11:30
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:11:30
This is the best episode of the entire season - fight me! The writing, the character development, the plot, the dialogue... We can go on and on. Jess is causing turmoil all over - from the townspeople to his family members to Rory, who, according to Lorelai, is completely over the situation. If you look very closely, you can see the rift forming be…
…
continue reading
1
4x12 Quirky, Bubbly, Flawed, Abusive Mother
1:18:36
1:18:36
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:18:36
Are you familiar with the films of Demi Moore? You're about to be! When that conversation is over, we're talking about all the storylines in this episode, and it's chaotic. Lane and Mrs. Kim are still at odds, as are Paris and Jamie. Luke's sister, Liz, is in town and we're learning more about her relationships with the men in her life. Trauma? Abu…
…
continue reading
1
4x11 I'm Putting My Foot Down, Parents!
1:17:09
1:17:09
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:17:09
There are three story lines in this episode, but let's be honest, we only care about one of them. The Lane vs. Mrs. Kim battle 4 years in the making is finally gracing our screens and we have so many feelings! Because we also have to talk about those pesky Gilmore Girls, we're exploring Luke and Lorelai's friendship/communication issues and why peo…
…
continue reading
1
4x10 Crepes in the Guest Room
1:13:37
1:13:37
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:13:37
Let's get something straight: friends don't just casually talk to each other about culs-de-sac. The "s" is silent. We're seeing a more human side of Michel, until he rolls baby Truman under the bed, and we're getting to know Jason, his traumatized dog, and his little quirks that lead us to a bedroom straight out of a magazine. Paris' new relationsh…
…
continue reading
1
4x09 Romances from the Hood
1:12:22
1:12:22
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:12:22
It's the podcast that keeps on giving! No, we're not talking about THIS podcast. We're talking about Scott Patterson's podcast, I Am All In. After we analyze his thoughts, we move on to Yale, where some heterosexuals are doing something with a ball - no homo! And we meet Brennan the Frog Guy. There've been a lot of frogs, man.…
…
continue reading
1
4x08 A Jug Full of Body Issues
1:11:08
1:11:08
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:11:08
There's a new podcast in town and we're positive it doesn't like us. Are the Gilmore Girls fatphobic? Is ASP fatphobic? We're discussing one of the most glaring instances of fat shaming from the show and talking about our own body issues. The marriage jug storyline may not be as useless as we once thought, Lorelai thinks Luke's life is her life but…
…
continue reading
1
4x07 The Digger You Deep
1:17:47
1:17:47
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:17:47
It's the only episode to win a major television award and for good reason! The costumes are gorgeous. But are the performances as amazing? Kirk is doing some light reading to prepare for the role of a lifetime and the band is auditioning new guitarists (spoiler alert: not all of them are winners). Have you ever heard of a couple wanting to get divo…
…
continue reading
1
4x06 Broccoli Tree Tart
1:06:18
1:06:18
Later Afspelen
Later Afspelen
Lijsten
Vind ik leuk
Leuk
1:06:18
Have you ever freaked out so badly that you paid someone 20$ for a tree? Neither have we. Have you ever gone to a party and said, "Hmm, you know what I need? A broccoli tart!" Neither have we.Door Eleni Philippopoulos and Jeffrey Davies
…
continue reading